Skip to content
Shopfest
SearchSavedOutfit finder
A quiet skincare moment in soft morning light
Shopfest · AI editorial concept

THE COMPARISON EDIT

Tubing mascaras: where to save, where to spend

Compare e.l.f., Thrive Causemetics and Hourglass by application, color choice and budget.

Compare the options ↓

By Shopfest Editorial Desk · Researched comparisons, not hands-on tests. Shopfest may earn commission through shopping links.

THE SHORT ANSWER

Start with what matters to you.

Start with e.l.f. if you are trying tubing mascara for the first time. Consider Thrive for color variety, or Hourglass if you want its premium formula and presentation.

At a glance.

Compare the key differences
ProductFormulaRemovalMain distinction
e.l.f. Cosmetics
Lash XTNDR Mascara		TubingWarm waterTapered silicone brush
Thrive Causemetics
Liquid Lash™ Extensions Tubing Mascara		TubingWarm waterExpanded shade selection
Hourglass
Unlocked Instant Extensions Mascara		TubingWarm waterLength and definition focus
e.l.f. Cosmetics Lash XTNDR Mascara product packaging; check selected size and shade at retailer

01 · The budget starting point

e.l.f. Cosmetics
Lash XTNDR Mascara

Lash XTNDR is the lowest-priced starting point in this group. Its tapered silicone brush and lengthening focus make it worth considering before paying more for the format.

The tradeoff. Build while lashes are still soft, following e.l.f.’s directions. A lower price does not tell us how it will wear on your lashes.

$8.00 recorded price before tax and shipping

Shop at e.l.f. Cosmetics

Existing ShopMy link. Commission eligibility depends on the retailer.

Product sourceRead the brand or retailer specifications ↗
Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash™ Extensions Tubing Mascara — Brynn (Rich Black)
Image: Thrive Causemetics

02 · For more color choices

Thrive Causemetics
Liquid Lash™ Extensions Tubing Mascara

Thrive’s Liquid Lash Extensions offers colors beyond standard black and brown. It is the most interesting option here if mascara is part of your color palette.

The tradeoff. Pay more than the e.l.f. option for a different range and formula; we have not established superior wear through testing.

$26.00 recorded price before tax and shipping

Shop at Thrive Causemetics

Existing ShopMy link. Commission eligibility depends on the retailer.

Product sourceRead the brand or retailer specifications ↗
Hourglass Unlocked Instant Extensions Mascara product packaging; check selected size and shade at retailer

03 · The premium alternative

Hourglass
Unlocked Instant Extensions Mascara

Unlocked is the luxury option for someone who already enjoys Hourglass and wants a tubing formula. Compare its black and espresso options against your usual eye makeup.

The tradeoff. The premium price is not evidence that it will outperform either less expensive option.

$34.00 recorded price before tax and shipping

Shop at Hourglass

Existing ShopMy link. Commission eligibility depends on the retailer.

Product sourceRead the brand or retailer specifications ↗

What makes this a useful comparison?

All three brands describe tubing formulas with warm-water removal. That shared format lets you compare the brush, shade and price rather than treating every mascara as interchangeable.

Decide what you want to change

If your current mascara works, identify a specific improvement before replacing it: easier removal, a different brush or a softer brown shade. We have not conducted side-by-side flaking, smudging or wear tests.

Keep exploring.